top of page
Search

Oscars 2024: Every Best Picture Nominee Ranked

jacobtsimmons97
Mar 4, 2024
9 min read

For the past three years, I have made it my mission to watch every single one of the films nominated for Best Picture at the Oscars before the date of the ceremony. On both occasions, I failed by one film (King Richard in 2022, Women Talking in 2023, case you’re interested). 


This year however, I did it! Hooray! 


To celebrate this momentous feat of me sitting on my arse for several hours whilst eating chocolate buttons, I thought I’d rank the ten pictures up for the coveted golden statuette this year. These are my personal opinions, a mixture of objective quality and individual preference, rather than how I think they’re going to do in the race. 


I have a 50% success rate of my favourites being winners so far, so fingers crossed we can get that number up to 67% per cent this year. 


You read that correctly. I rounded up to two significant figures. 


#10: Killers of the Flower Moon 


Oh boy, time to dredge this up again. 


I was way out of step with most of the people I spoke to about Martin Scorsese’s Killers of the Flower Moon, which I saw in the cinema last year, as seemingly everyone I spoke to loved it. 


I was desperate to join them; I loved the setting of Osage County and the idea of a story pitting the Native population against the scheming White folks; I thought there were some great performances, especially from Robert de Niro as the conniving William “King” Hale. But it was just so bloody long. 


As I said in my full review of the movie, I don’t hate long films. I’m a Lord of the Rings fan, for goodness sake, but Killers did not earn its gargantuan 206 minute runtime. It felt undisciplined, like people were too scared to tell Scorsese to take stuff out or trim certain scenes. I was going crazy in my seat waiting for it to end, which made me laugh hysterically at the barrage of random cameos towards the end. Jack White? Really? 


I really disliked this film, and whilst I can see why it fits the bill of an Oscar movie, it’s right at the bottom of the pile for me. 


#9: Anatomy of a Fall


Speaking of films that bored me. 


Justine Triet’s Anatomy of a Fall was the penultimate movie I needed to fill out my bingo card, one of the few I hadn’t already watched before the nominations were announced. Once again, it got rave reviews from some of my most trusted film sources, and I was pumped to enjoy this story about a woman whose husband dies in a tragic fall and the struggle that emerges afterwards to find the truth. 


Instead, what I got was little more interesting or entertaining than your standard police procedural, or “grey BBC drama” as I said in my full review. I failed to connect with the central character, which let everything else down, and a movie that others said flew by dragged on and on and on. 


It’s great to see a movie with several scenes not in English get the nod, as well as Triet getting a Best Director nomination too, but I was left deflated by Anatomy of a Fall and I am in absolutely no rush to ever see it again. 


On the plus side, it did feature the best acting by a dog I have ever seen, so well done Messi.


#8: Barbie


How is this somehow the most controversial nomination on this list? It’s a film about a plastic doll. 


I had a great time taking part in the Barbenheimer craze that swept the world over the Summer of 2023, seeing them both the day after they came out. I didn’t know what to expect from Greta Gerwig’s Barbie, only that it was going to be weird, but for me, it was the wrong kind of weird. 


Everything felt quite surface level; the jokes about existentialism; the critique of major corporations; the feminism. Whilst it’s important for these messages to be expressed in a direct way so that everyone can understand them, it didn’t feel particularly artistic, and when something is up for Best Picture, that’s the lens you have to view it through. 


Obviously Ryan Gosling was terrific and the soundtrack produced some absolute bangers, but a Best Picture? Really? 


It’s impossible to hate on the first solely female-directed film to generate over $1 billion - if anyone deserved that honour, it was Greta - but I felt kinda disappointed by Barbie. I wanted it to go further, to be more out there, but maybe I just love the patriarchy too much. 


It’s about horses, right?


#7: The Holdovers


I know it’s been said before, but The Holdovers wasn’t released in the UK before Christmas and that makes absolutely zero sense. 


Alexander Payne’s tale of a grouchy teacher, his reluctant pupil, and a grieving cook sharing the holidays together was touted as a new Yuletide classic, the ultimate soother for a frozen soul, something to make you forget about your troubles and embrace the magic of the movies. 


I thought it was fine. 


The connecting stories felt too disparate for me, and it never cracked my heart in the way I wanted it to. Da’Vine Joy Randolph is having the time of her life on the awards circuit right now, which is so much fun to see, but I was left indifferent to her much-lauded performance. Shoutout to Dominic Sessa, though, my favourite of the main trio. 


As I wasn’t massively taken by the story, I didn’t really care for the grainy 70s aesthetic either, which a lot of people seemed to go mad for. Barton College in the snow was fun, as I said when I reviewed this the first time round, but is a bit of the white stuff enough to make a good movie? 


To be fair, it depends on what white stuff you’re talking about. 


I promise I’ll stop dumping on beloved films now.


#6: Oppenheimer


Here it is. The big one. 


Christopher Nolan’s newest addition to his collection of tortured handsome men is J. Robert Oppenheimer, the titular character of this story about the father of the atomic bomb. Oppy is one of my favourite historical figures, a really interesting guy, so I was excited to see what Nolski would do with him. As it turns out, what he did was ignore large parts of his story and make him out to be way smoother and suaver than he ever was in real life. 


I’m not a massive Nolan person and I’m subtly suspicious of anyone who is. His films mostly look the same, are usually quite complicated, and you can often count the number of prominent female characters on one hand after a particularly violent lawnmower accident. If there weren’t naturally two women in Oppenheimer’s story, you can bet your ass either Emily Blunt or Florence Pugh would have been cut.


I liked most of the acting and the scene with THE EVENT was understandably breathtaking, but Oppenheimer missed the mark for me. It didn’t spend nearly enough time on Oppy’s guilt about unleashing hell on Earth, the courtroom scenes were quite boring, and if one more person makes a film half in black-and-white, I’m going to scream. 


I do not get the hype at all.


#5: Maestro


And now we move onto films I actually thought were pretty great. 


Maestro, the only one of these movies I didn’t see on a big screen, is the story of Leonard Bernstein, a pioneering American composer who lived a double life due to his homosexuality. Alongside his directing duties, Bradley Cooper also plays Lenny and does a decent job in bringing his eccentric mannerisms to life in a manner that isn’t too goofy. 


I could have used a bit more music in the film - I loved the scene where Cooper furiously conducts an orchestra for several minutes - but I thought it was nicely laid out. Although, it did the black-and-white thing that I just ranted about, so zero stars. 


What really pulled this thing up for me was Carey Mulligan as Felicia Montealegre, Lenny’s wife. I gushed about her performance in my full review, so I’ll keep it brief here; she is a general talent and should be given all of the small shiny men. 


Without her, I wouldn’t have liked Maestro nearly as much, but sometimes one astounding actor is all it takes to turn a good film into a great one. 


#4: Poor Things


Poor Things from Yorgos Lanthimos was the level of mentalness I wanted from Barbie, although I definitely wouldn’t have expected as much nudity from a film marketed at children. 


Adapted from the Alasdair Grey novel of the same name, this is the tale of Bella Baxter (Emma Stone), a mad scientist’s creation who learns the trials and tribulations of the world through her interactions with various outlandish figures. 


Lanthimos did an amazing job bringing the book to life (even though it was set in London instead of Glasgow for some reason) and the cinematography, set design, and overall directing was gorgeous. Although, and I can’t believe I’m complaining about this for a third time in as many entries, it also did the black-and-white thing! Stop! 


The story was wild and varied (if a little flabby towards the end) and I thought it achieved its pro-female empowerment message effectively. As I said in my full review, Bella is completely in charge of her decisions, with the rest of the world bending to her will, not the other way around.


Stone was utterly untouchable in the lead, carrying the movie on her back and crafting a new cinematic icon. The supporting cast also did well, with Mark Ruffalo deploying the greatest cinematic C-bombs since Richard E. Grant in Withnail and I. 


A jolly good time.


#3: American Fiction 


American Fiction by Cord Jefferson also did a “black-and-white thing”, but not the kind that I’ve been complaining about. 


Jeffrey Wright is Thelonious “Monk” Ellison, a subtly pompous writer who concots a stereotypically “Black” book to send to publishers as a joke. They take it seriously, however, and Monk reluctantly becomes a best-seller. 


As well as presenting a smart and funny satire of the publishing industry, the art industry, and White guilt, American Fiction is also a family story, as Monk reconnects with his roots after a tragedy. This is the film’s greatest strength; instead of leaving one story to be overexposed, both are given equal weighting and both are highly enjoyable for different reasons. It rides the line perfectly with great supporting performances from Leslie Uggams, Tracee Ellis Ross, Sterling K. Brown, and my boy Raymond Anthony Thomas, aka Maynard. Read my original thoughts for context.


Comedies don’t usually do well at the Oscars, but this is more than just a funny film. It has a great heart and some really sharp things to say that never veer into preachiness, with Wright killing it as a leading man. I didn’t think I’d hate it, but I enjoyed it way more than I thought I would.


#2: Past Lives


I saw Celine Song’s Past Lives last summer and it was the best new thing I watched all year. 


Drawing on Song’s own experiences of living in Canada as a South Korean woman, the film follows Na Young/Nora, who follows the same path. She is tied to each of her homes via two men; an old flame and her current husband. When the childhood sweetheart comes to visit, it causes reflections and internal strife out the wazoo. 


This sounds like the sort of premise that would be really affecting if you’d gone through a similar thing, but might exclude those who hadn’t. Let me tell you that, even as the most Southern English person of all time, I related to this film hard. 


To me, it was about the path not taken in love, what my life could have been like had certain romantic decisions gone in different directions. It was about loving someone from afar and loving someone who is so closely tied to a specific time and place in your mind, but who you know you’ll probably never be with in the way you want to. 


That is a crazy thing to feel whilst watching a movie. 


Past Lives is also stunning, by the way, a truly beautiful film. How Song managed to pull this off with her very first feature is astounding, and I cannot wait to see what she does next. 


A gem. 


#1: The Zone of Interest


The Zone of Interest by Jonathan Glazer was the tenth and final film I watched on this quest, courtesy of the fine folks at the BFI Southbank. It follows Rudolf Höss, the commandant of the Auschwitz death camp during World War II, who just so happens to live on the grounds with his idyllic family.  


This was always going to be a home run if the balance was struck right, and Glazer knocked it out of the park. The film is unbearably tense, as you are fully aware of the horrors going on just over the garden wall without it ever being shoved down your throat. The movie’s sound design is on another level, and not just when the camp is overheard, but in the constant, unsettling accompaniments to everyday life; footsteps; babies crying; people chattering. The world is going on as normal, but it is anything but. 


The review I wrote of The Zone of Interest is my longest to date, because there is so much to say about it. You could get an entire thesis out of the night-vision sequences alone and still have room to talk about how amazing Sandra Hüller is or how striking the colours are or the use of Hansel and Gretel, a story about someone being cooked alive in an oven… 


This is a movie you simply have to see and, for my money, the best of the bunch at this year’s Academy Awards. 



 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page