top of page
Search

Film Review: Killers Of The Flower Moon

jacobtsimmons97
Oct 21, 2023
4 min read



Length is very important… ok, now that you’ve made all those jokes in your head, let’s move on to talking about Martin Scorsese’s Killers of the Flower Moon.


The all-time director returns for a story about greed, deception, family, oil, owls, hats, and bigger hats. Ernest Burkhart (Leonardo DiCaprio) is the nephew of William King Hale (Robert De Niro), a cattle rancher and stand-up guy who wants to infiltrate the local Osage Native American population to get his hands on their oil money. This is all based on a true story, by the way, as chronicled in a 2017 book by David Grann. Scorsese had been eyeing up the project for a while, but got distracted producing all 400 hours of The Irishman, which, in hindsight, should have been a huge red flag.


The “Di/De” brigade are joined in the principle cast by Lily Gladstone, who plays Mollie Kile, the unfortunate woman who ends up embroiled in the White men’s scheme when she marries Ernest. All three are excellent, with Leo portraying a snivelling, gutless capitalist who gets way out of his depth, Gladstone performing well with the severely limited screen time she was given, and Bobby absolutely stealing the show as the cold, calculating King. He was by far my favourite character, well-written and performed, with particular touches like the way he knew the Osage language and the genuine kindness he showed to the people he was conspiring against going a long way to elevate him above your typical Western mogul type. This may well go down as one of RDN’s best roles, and that’s saying something.


As this is a MarScor production set in the sprawling Oklahoma desert, it naturally looks fantastic. It’s not like there are dozens of fancy camera tricks in it, but everything is bathed in this glorious early 20th Century glow that is a joy to consume. Although Killers of the Flower Moon will be coming to Apple TV following its short theatrical run, it was clearly shot with the big screen in mind. The town of Fairfax, where most of the action takes place, is brimming with life, beautifully constructed and populated with a host of top notch extras and minor characters. It’ll make you want to live there… well, maybe not the parts where everyone gets murdered.


And, of course, it’s important to recognise the good work that this project does in bringing to light the plight of Native Americans at the hands of White people. Despite the protection of the almighty dollar, the Osage were near-powerless to stop the spree of killings targeted against their people, with Mollie being forced to go speak directly with President Coolidge himself to get something done. Side note - is this the most prolific movie ever to feature Calvin Coolidge? Can’t say I’ve ever seen him in anything else.


As you can tell, I have a lot of good things to say about Killers of the Flower Moon. So, is it one of my top movies of the year? Nope. Not even close.


This thing fell off a cliff towards the end, pretty much as soon as Jesse Plemons’ FBI investigator Tom White turned up. Actually, I say “at the end”, but this was probably about halfway through this gargantuan slog. After reaching the emotional high-point of Ernest’s capture and the unravelling of King’s plot, the story meandered towards its end point with a baffling combination of lethargy and hurriedness. It was more than happy to let characters monologue for minutes at a time, but it also rushed through integral scenes between Ernest and Mollie, the death of one of their children, and felt the need to do a bizarre summary of the story at the end in the form of a radio play. A play that, obviously, Scorsese cast himself in to read the final line. I know the guy’s been around for ages and can basically do what he wants, but come on, that’s self-indulgence to the nth degree.


On the topic of cameos, they go into overdrive in the final act. John Lithgow turns up as a prosecutor, Academy Award-winning Brendan Fraser is a lawyer with about ten lines of shouty dialogue, and one of the other radio actors is Jack White from The White Stripes. I was close to going mad anyway, but these random apparitions tipped me over the edge.


The film had stalled so much that I found myself completely emotionally numb to key scenes towards its climax. Ernest and his uncle’s dramatic exchange between prison bars bounced off me like a rubber ball, when it should have been a key and memorable scene. As for Mollie, it felt like she never got the chance to deliver a satisfying reckoning to the husband who had caused her so much pain, which would have been a bad call regardless of the film’s length.


A film being three-and-a-half hours is not an inherent sign that it’s going to be bad. I love the Lord of the Rings trilogy and the big Marvel finales, so I’d be a hypocrite if I thought this way, but Killers of the Flower Moon did not earn this runtime. I thought it was going to, as the first half benefited greatly from being given so much room to breathe, but it got to the point where the credits could have rolled several times and it still wasn’t done, leaving all the excellent acting and direction mired in an emotional muck.


The length of a film isn’t just important because stupid millennials like me have no attention spans and the bladder control of a frightened rodent; it’s also an exercise in discipline, in pacing, in making sure that the bits that deserve to be in the final cut don’t get bogged down by the bits that don’t. If somebody wants to try and make a tighter version of this and send it to me, I’ll gladly watch it again, but as it stands, this is the first and last time I will ever visit Fairfax, King Hale, and the Osage, and I feel awful about that.


On the plus side, it has made me interested in reading the book, which I might honestly complete in less time than the movie.


 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page