Anatomy Of A Fall - Dull Proceedural Gets Its Day In Court
Anatomy Of A Fall is one of those films that makes me wonder if I’m actually as cultured and pretentiously knobby as I think I am. Everywhere I look, it’s getting rave reviews from people I love and respect, and yet, when I watched it, I was bored.
Like, very bored.
From director Justine Triet comes a multi-language crime drama about a writer named Sandra (Sandra Hüller) who may or may not have pushed her husband off their roof to his death. On paper, this sounds like something I would enjoy; a tense, twisty examination not of whether or not she did it, but whether “the truth” matters and what “the truth” even is. This is definitely what the film was going for and, in theory, I can see that it achieved that goal. Sadly, theory and practice are two very different things.
I’d like to start this review with some praise for the movie’s cast, all of whom I thought were good to great. Among my favourites was Milo Machado-Graner, who played Daniel, the blind son of the afflicted couple caught in the middle of this whole tragic mess. For such a young actor, he handled the hefty subject matter really well and played his part as the lynch pin of the case really well. This sort of role is easy to miss when done well, but very easy to spot when done poorly, so kudos to Milo for not standing out.
Antoine Reinartz was really good as the relentless prosecutor, leaving no stone unturned in his quest to send Sandra down. He was genuinely quite frightening in places and, most importantly, you believed everything he was saying. When my horrendous crimes against humanity get discovered, I want him to be my lawyer.
But the real star of the show was easily this year’s breakout performer who looks set to take the showbiz world by storm – Messi the dog. As the family’s loyal pet, he was a constant presence, but never felt out of place or like a distraction. Also, he actually had to act when he was force-fed some aspirin pills, and I can say with certainty that he was better than several humans I’ve seen try to perform. That Palm Dog Award he won was well deserved.
Unfortunately, now that the talk about good boys is out of the way, it’s time to have a moan.
First off, this is a long film at 152 minutes and I felt every single one of them. The lengthy court scenes of endless back-and-forth between the two parties dragged like mad, to the point where I was almost completely numb to anything that was being said. The actual investigative parts played out like all the worst parts of your standard grey BBC police drama (one of my least favourite genres) and instead of feeling like I’d been given unedited success to the inner workings of French law, I realised why most shows and movies decide to take this stuff out.
Speaking of French, that’s the primary language in this movie, seeing as the murder takes place in the Alps. However, Sandra, being German, doesn’t speak it very well, and so conducts some of her testimonies in English. This results in several conversations that are half in French, half in English, and whilst there is a translator present, they flow way too smoothly to fit the slow realism of the rest of the piece. Sandra goes from barely being able to string a sentence together to understanding complex concepts, before replying in English, which the prosecutor just so happens to be fluent in. This may seem like a nitpick, but it really irked me and took me out of the drama.
My favourite scene was easily the recorded argument between Sandra and husband Samuel (Samuel Theis), part of which was acted out. This is the only time you get to see any sort of fire from any actor and, crucially, you understand the real dynamic behind this couple. Unfortunately, this comes way too late in the day and doesn’t last nearly long enough.
Everything before and after this scene sagged heavily, as I slumped back into my chair.
I can’t say that I hated Anatomy of a Fall, because the acting was too good and it had its moments story-wise, but so much of it was bogged down in the muck of legal paperwork, that I can’t say I enjoyed it either.
Maybe this is on me; maybe I’m too simple or too impatient to enjoy something so complex and deep. All I can say is sorry not sorry, and that I gave this film the same score on Letterboxd I gave to Sonic the Hedgehog.
Deal with it.




Comments