Poor Things - A Stone Cold Classic (Cinema Review)
If you’ve read my “Worst Films I Saw In 2023” post (if not, then why hath thee betrayed me so?), then you’ll know that I did not have the best of times with Yorgos Lanthimos’ The Lobster.
However, this being my first experience with his work, I was determined not to be put off, and went into his latest film, Poor Things, with an open mind. Thank God I did, because I had an absolutely wonderful time with this mad, sad, and so very bad movie.
I’ve never bothered with keeping spoilers out of these reviews, but I do want to write about how I think they can affect viewing this work. I read in many reviews after I’d seen Poor Things the key detail that Emma Stone’s Bella Baxter is a deceased woman imbued with the brain of her unborn child. To me, this revelation was one of the key points of the early stages of the movie, as it not only explained Bella’s childlike state, but also set her apart from the traditional Frankenstein mould that I was expecting. Personally, I preferred not knowing this information, so I think it was bad form to give it away ahead of time. If I thought more than three people read these posts, then I wouldn’t have said anything, but I think I’m safe.
Anyway, on with the review proper.
The cinematography here is massively stylised, as Victorian London (and later various other locations) is transformed in a steampunky, post-modern, MC Escher painting, full of impossible buildings, futuristic anomalies, and some very unique-looking people. This weirdly grounded the project within its own logic, allowing the audience to buy in to some of the more ludicrous actions. I’ve seen better realised fantasy worlds for sure, but this did exactly what it needed to do.
Jerskin Fendrix, whose real name is the somehow-even-cooler Joscelin Dent-Pooley, provides a score as eclectic and uncanny as the visuals. His atonal, often formless accompaniments to the action also add to the world, shaping the story in ways dialogue simply cannot. There is no element of Poor Things that isn’t distinctly its own and that works massively in its favour; a story as bizarre as this has all the trappings of a cult classic, and the mise-en-scene only compounds that further.
Thank you GCSE media for teaching me that word.
I feel like I can’t go on any longer without talking about the elephant in the room; the usually red-headed, frequently stark naked elephant.
Emma Stone is the beating heart of this film. The whole thing hinges on Bella’s journey from sheltered child to naïve adolescent taking her first steps into the light to confident, sexually-liberated modern woman, and Stone plays every stage of the journey to perfection.
The physical performance needed to portray childlike Bella is nothing to turn your nose up at, even if it does feel a bit “first week of theatre school”. Stone carries this off with aplomb, often revelling in the wanton destruction she causes, which gives her woman-baby character a more adult edge.
Bella’s trajectory mirrors that of a classic teen coming-of-age protagonist; a well-meaning, but clueless dreamer who gets dealt some harsh life lessons. But rather than missing out on the prom or watching Jeremy make out with someone else (curse you, Jeremy!), Bella is experiencing a whole life condensed into 140 minutes. It’s a lot to deal with, and it doesn’t always land, but for the most part, you’re with her every step of the way, rooting for her against the slew of manipulative men who want to shape her to their desires.
That last part is where some people take issue with Poor Things. To some people I've heard from, Bella is little more than a sexual fantasy who “furiously jumps” on a bunch of gross men and is made to like it. I didn’t see it that way at all. To me, Bella is in complete control of everything around her. She commands when she has sex, when she visits new places or meets new people, or when she gives large sums of money away. The men simply follow in her wake. They might think they’re in charge, but all of them end up getting their comeuppance in some form or another. One of them literally has their brain taken out and put into a goat. If that’s not karma, then nothing is.
I also didn't find the sex scenes sexy at all, more absurd. If you were able to maintain a stiffy (or whatever your gender's version of a stiffy is) whilst watching a Frenchman bang Emma Stone in front of his kids, then all the power to you, but it couldn't be me.
Speaking of the men, let’s talk about the stand-out supporting cast member. Mark Ruffalo is absolutely electric as the caddish Duncan Wedderburn; over-the-top to a laughable extent, but just evil enough to still be detestable. Never before have I seen such wonderful deployment of the C-bomb, even if Ruffalo’s English accent is about as solid as Dick Van Dyke’s. He more than earned his Oscar nomination, and even though he probably won’t win, this is easily the best role I’ve ever seen him play.
Though it wasn’t perfect - the brothel scenes went on a bit too long for my liking - Poor Things achieved most of what it set out to do. It reminded us all how masterful Stone is as a leading lady, crafted a fantastically vibrant and completely original setting, and delivered on a story that celebrated female sexuality instead of punishing it.
Well played, Mr. Lanthimos, all is forgiven. Not that you care what I think.




Comments