top of page
Search

The Holdovers - A Fuzzy Outline Of A Warm And Fuzzy Film (Cinema Review)

jacobtsimmons97
Feb 7, 2024
4 min read

Here’s a fun fact - I actually paid money for a ticket to see Alexander Payne’s new film, The Holdovers, but then I got sick, so I had to cancel my viewing, along with two other cinema trips. Clearly I did something terrible in a past life… who am I kidding, it was in this life. 


Not one to let a little karmic retribution get in my way, I got back on the horse and went to see the film in a much crappier cinema, in a seat directly under some house lights that didn’t get dimmed. Maybe this is why I was somewhat disappointed with a movie that has gotten rave reviews across the board, but we won’t know unless we get stuck into the review. 


My big worry going into The Holdovers was that I’d basically figured out how it was going to go down ahead of time. Rich prep school kid gets stuck there over the holidays, forms an “unlikely bond” (I hate that phrase) with his grumpy old teacher and the cook who is suffering from bereavement, various stuff happens, and the real Christmas was the friends we made along the way. I’m being facetious (Me? Never.) but honestly, I wasn’t far off. 


The three main players in our tale are teacher Paul Hunham (Paul Giamatti), student Angus Tulley (Dominic Sessa), and cook Mary Lamb (Da’Vine Joy Randolph). Yes, her name is Mary Lamb. If her middle name isn’t “Hadalittle”, then what are we even doing? 


Giamatti gave a typically strong performance as the graceless, history-obsessed academic, although I struggled to buy into the scenes where he’d apparently had a change of heart. To me, he still seemed like the same abrasive outcast he’d been throughout the movie, but at least now he’d made friends with… one of his students? Is that the moral of the story? Yikes. 


Randolph got a lot of praise for her performance, with the Best Supporting Actress Oscar pretty much tied up. Sadly, I failed to see what all the fuss was about; she was good, but a lot of her screentime boiled down to her slagging off the kids in a Boston accent. The character was a little one note for me - it mostly boiled down to “has dead son” - so maybe that was it, but I have nothing against her personally. Hopefully now she’s got some more exposure out of this role, she can go on and do bigger and better things. 


The standout of the main trio for me was Sessa, who pitched Tulley’s sarcastic, curt, yet sympathetic teen pretty much spot on. At just 21/22 (Wikipedia can’t seem to decide), he is clearly on the way to big things. Maybe he and Randolph can be in a film where he calls her names for two hours instead. Then again, maybe not. 


Let’s do a David Bowie and talk about Sound and Vision. I really enjoyed the setting of Barton Academy in the snow. The scenes outside were definitely my favourite, but being inside the buildings, with their grand wooden walls and portraits of old White guys, was fun too. I didn’t really care when they left the school, as I was completely uninterested in seeing what Boston looks like at Christmas (cold), but it was pretty essential to the plot, so I’ll allow it. 


Before we move on, can I just say that I don’t give a single hoot that the film “looked like it was from the 70s”? The old timey Universal logo and rating certificate were fun, but I hate it when films try to get clever with really basic aesthetic choices. I don’t care that half your film is in black and white, I don’t care that you’ve put a grainy filter over the top of it, I don’t care that you’ve shot the thing in 4:3. Moan over. 


One of the real highlights was the soundtrack, which contained a great mix of classic Christmas songs and soft, finger-picky guitar tracks that achieved exactly the right effect. I was disappointed that Badfinger’s No Matter What, a song that featured heavily in the trailer, was reduced to a cameo on the radio and, for some reason, is not on the official soundtrack. What you got against Badfinger, Payne? Is it because they’re Welsh? If so, then I totally understand. 


My biggest problem with The Holdovers was that it felt disjointed. It spent time building up a bunch of other kids that were staying for Christmas, only to take them out of the story and never really come back to them. Hunham and Tulley eventually got to bond, but way too late in the day for me to actually care. Also, as relatable as it may be, I’ve seen way too many stories about kids with absentee dads finding a father figure in a lonely old man, and this did nothing to elevate itself above mid-table. What I’m saying is, it wasn’t Up, but then again, few things are. 


I really wanted to come out of the less-good cinema with a big smile on my face having had my soul rejuvenated by a new holiday classic, but it just didn’t happen. Whilst The Holdovers had some really nice ideas, it didn’t follow through enough with any of them, and left me feeling majorly empty when all was said and done. 


No doubt it will still pick up some Oscars and that will be lovely, but for me, I don’t think I’ll be returning to it any time soon. Still, it was a better film referencing the Peloponnesian War than the last Indiana Jones, so that’s something.


 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page