top of page
Search

American Fiction - Come For The Satire, Stay For Everything Else

jacobtsimmons97
Feb 20, 2024
3 min read

I was pleasantly surprised when American Fiction got nominated for a Best Picture Oscar. I thought that The Holdovers would have been enough comedy for the Academy this year, but sure enough, Cord Jefferson’s tale of a Black author who writes a stereotypically “Black” book to take on the publishing industry found a way in.


Now that I’ve seen it, I can confirm that this was a good choice. 


Thelonious “Monk” Ellison is our hero, portrayed brilliantly by Jeffrey Wright. He can best be described as “grumpy” with a constant chip on his shoulder about how life has turned out and how nobody is interested in buying the books he’s written. This is what leads him to take on the pseudonym Stagg R. Leigh (do you get it?) and pen a book about the “Black experience” that essentially boils down to gang violence, absentee fathers, and all the other stuff he thinks White people want to read about it. In true Producers style, he’s right, and Leigh’s book is a smash. D’oh. 


But that’s not all that’s going on here. 


In the midst of his unexpected (and unwanted) success, Monk is also drawn into a personal spiral following the death of his sister and the worsening of his mother’s Alzheimer’s. Throw in a new girlfriend and a brother who is a complete law unto himself, and our boy has a lot on his mind. 


Both stories, the book and Monk’s personal life, are given equal billing. There’s no “B plot” or “side story”, they’re both as important as each other and, in my opinion at least, both are as entertaining as each other. I’ve seen some complaints that the family drama distracts from the publishing industry satire, but I found that they complimented each other brilliantly. The book stuff was the big, high concept thought experiment, whilst the family stuff was more personal, easier to get to grips with. I wouldn’t have changed anything about either of them - well, except maybe to give Maynard, the town cop and all-round smooth customer, more screen time. Where’s this guy’s Oscar nom? 


Speaking of award-winning performances, Jeffrey Wright would be a more-than-worthy Best Actor if his name got called at the Oscars. He embodies all of Monk’s traits, good or bad, to perfection, creating a worthwhile lead character for the others to play off. He is funny when he needs to be, angry when needs to be, and an asshole when he needs to be, and I truly cannot envision the role going to anyone else. 


Elsewhere on the cast list. Leslie Uggams does a fantastic job playing Monk’s ailing mother, which only makes her battle with dementia all the more harrowing to watch. Stirling K. Brown is up for an Oscar for Best Supporting Actor for his role as Cliff, Monk’s brother, and whilst he was good, I wouldn’t have been outraged if he didn’t get the nom. 


What I do think is a travesty is that we only spent a handful of minutes with Lisa, Monk’s sister. Tracee Ellis Ross is just as acerbic and sharp as her on-screen brother, trading barbs with him in her limited screen time whilst also getting across the sadness of her recent divorce and the plight of her mother, for whom she serves as carer. Her death does move the plot along, so I get it, it’s just a shame Ross had to be so good in such a tiny part. 


The book plot is executed really well; just the right balance of ridiculous and realistic. Some of the characters in the publishing industry are definitely overblown parodies, but they all serve a purpose of highlighting just how ludicrous the demands on creatives of colour are. In fact, none of the White characters are anything but laughable, with no self-awareness and no idea that, in trying to be helpful, they’re making it all worse. This may sound like a criticism, but the lack of nuance chimes with the point American Fiction is trying to make, and it’s only natural Monk’s exaggerated manuscript be met by equally excessive responses. 


I had a blast with American Fiction. It kind of had its cake and ate it too, providing both a thought-provoking take on modern race relations whilst also offering a strong and dramatic narrative full of great characters. It’s one of the stronger Oscar contenders for this year, and I for one can’t wait to watch it lose to Oppenheimer. 

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page