top of page
Search

Maestro - A Decent Biopic Carey-ed By Stellar Performance (Cinema Review)

jacobtsimmons97
Jan 15, 2024
3 min read

Awards season is fully underway, so of course the time has come for me to review a biopic of a closeted gay composer directed by its star and half shot in black and white. 


Maestro comes to us from that nice boy, Bradley Cooper, marking his second directorial effort after the 37th version of A Star is Born. Sticking with a musical theme, Cooper portrays real-life composer and conductor, Leonard Bernstein, who made a splash in the worlds of both classical and mainstream music and became the first American-born conductor to be considered a global great. 


As well as his career highs and lows, the film also examines Bernstein’s life as a secret gay man, although not as secretive as maybe he should have been, considering how openly he cavorts with men in the movie. Sounds like a good premise for a movie, and it is, but one that may have hampered itself from the very beginning. 


Sometimes when it comes to films based on true events, the events themselves can overpower the interpretation. Stuff like this really has to earn itself, or face the criticism that it should have just been a documentary, and whilst there are moments of artistic flourish in Maestro, particularly the scene inspired by Bernstein’s musical On the Town, sometimes it was clearly relying on the story to pick everything else up. 


Cooper’s direction is interesting, with lots of nice long takes and well-framed shots, but he is by no means immune to Academy-grabbing tropes. The first half of the movie (the stuff set in the past) was in black and white, which is becoming a really horrible cliche that I would gladly see banned, or at least severely limited. Watch out for a similar moan during my Poor Things review.


If not for one thing, then I would have condemned Maestro as just another Oscar-bait release that will be quickly forgotten about once the gongs are handed out. I would now like to spend the rest of this review gushing over that one particular thing, and her name is Carey Hannah Mulligan. 


The star, who between this and Saltburn had one hell of a 2023, plays Felicia Montealegre, Bernstein’s wife of 27 years. When she meets Lenny at the beginning of the movie, they are both young, carefree, and ambitious, but the stress of life in the public eye and Bernstein’s inner conflict soon start to take their toll. 


Their relationship is at the core of this film, as everything else that happens is framed through the lens of how it affects the Bernsteins and their bond. Even though Lenny is quite clearly a homosexual, he still very much cares and loves his wife, and as more than just a close friend. Cooper and Mulligan have a stunning chemistry together, fully believable as either madly in love or as complex life partners. 


Despite the various trials and tribulations they suffer, they never truly get angry with one another. This is highlighted by a tremendous scene where the couple “argue” in their New York apartment without ever raising their voices, such is their respect for one another. This was a really tricky dynamic to get right, and I’m delighted to say that they did.


Felicia is fabulously wealthy, a successful actor married to a successful musician with three children whom she adores, and yet, something is still missing. She is living a lie. This is constantly written across Mulligan’s face, never failing to remind you that, although all may seem well on the outside, internally, she is barely keeping it together. 


As subtle as all that is, Mulligan really comes into her own after Felicia is diagnosed with terminal breast cancer. She stays just the right side of melodrama to provide a harrowing snapshot of a woman at the end of her life, calm and composed one moment, in floods of tears the next. All of the good work Mulligan put in before this moment pays off, as I found myself genuinely lamenting her plight and genuinely mourning her eventual death. 


Whilst Maestro brought some nice things to the table, Mulligan’s performance dramatically elevated it for me. Cooper was good, but was completely blown away by his on-screen wife, who I think we can all now agree is simply one of the best actors working today. 


I don’t expect many awards will come this film’s way, based on the stiff competition out there, but if Carey doesn’t win something, I will be very upset. 

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page