top of page
Search

The Iron Claw - Subjectivity Got Me In A Headlock

jacobtsimmons97
Mar 8, 2024
3 min read

If there’s one thing you need to know about me, it’s that I am a massive fan of professional wrestling. 


I’ve been into the bizarre sport-theatre-dance hybrid since I was a teenager. It’s gotten me through some tough times, it’s something I share with some of my best friends, and part of my living is made by writing about it for a YouTube channel (shoutout Cultaholic Wrestling). 


Wrestling has been largely overlooked by the movie industry, with the notable exception of Darren Aronofsky’s The Wrestler (which I thought was fine), so you can imagine my excitement when it was announced that writer and director Sean Curkin was working on The Iron Claw, based on the very true and very sad story of the Von Erichs. 


As a wrestling fan, I knew the Von Erichs already. They were royalty during the 70s and 80s down in Texas and famous in the wrestling community for having one of the most horrendous stories in the business. With a plot ready-made for the big screen and an absolutely killer cast, The Iron Claw looked set to become one of the best wrestling movies ever made and, now that I’ve seen it, I can confidently say that is true. 


It’s a low bar, mind you, but even so. 


The story is what carries this film above everything, as the tragedy slowly unfolds over a number of years with enough milestone points to hang key scenes on. The real-life brothers were thick as thieves, bonded by blood and a passion for the wrestling ring. The film did a great job in presenting that bond, as Zac Effron (Kevin), Jeremy Allen White (Kerry), Harrison Dickinson (David), and Stanley Simons (Mike) were very believable as loving siblings. 


The standout performer for me was Holt McCallany as Fritz Von Erich, the family patriarch and de facto villain of the piece. He pushes his boys to unbearable lengths in a vainglorious attempt to get a world champion in the family, but even when he’s being unthinkably stubborn and bullish, you never fully feel like he doesn’t love his kids. This is just how he shows it - it’s wrong, but not in his mind. McCallany exudes presence in the same way the real Fritz did; a giant of the wrestling world placing gigantic pressure on his sons. 


Culkin made the wise choice to leave out the fact that Fritz changed his name to play a Nazi character. That would have complicated things.


That segues into the gripes section of the review; the same segment I include whenever I review a biopic of something I know a bit about. The Iron Claw took quite a few liberties with the truth; Kerry’s accident happened a few years later than it did on-screen; Kevin didn’t find Kevin’s body, Fritz did; Kevin has two daughters before he had two sons, which would have invalidated the film’s ending line; and, most glaringly of all, there was a whole other Von Erich brother that they left out. 


Chris Von Erich was also an aspiring wrestler who also failed to live up to his father’s lofty standards and, like two of his siblings, took his own life. The filmmakers have said that they excluded Chris because they felt like the film couldn’t handle another death, which I understand, but I also can’t shake a slight feeling of betrayal left by his omission. There’s a larger debate to be had here about how “true” a “true story” needs to be, but this one irked me, possibly because I was too close to the subject matter beforehand. 


I will say that the actual wrestling looked great. The actors clearly did their homework when it came to the style of grappling that was popular at the time and the presentation of the wrestling TV shows was spot-on; a glorious homage to the campiness of the 70s and 80s. 


As a fan, it was great to see famous names from the day pop up as side characters. However, Aaron Dean Eisenberg has clearly never seen a Ric Flair promo in his life. I know a lot of people have ragged on him for this, but I could have done a better job and have done whilst drunk at parties. 


For people who aren’t as attached to the world of wrestling as I am, The Iron Claw is a fantastic drama that will leave you sick to your stomach in the best way possible. Unfortunately for me, I couldn’t get myself out of the mindset of a know-it-all, which is entirely my own fault, but also meant that I couldn’t truly experience how great this film was. 


Most people have normal hobbies though, so you’ll be fine.



 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page