top of page
Search

Oscars 2024 - Head Vs. Heart Predictions

jacobtsimmons97
Mar 9, 2024
6 min read

The 96th Academy Awards (or the 2024 Oscars for normal people) are nearly here, and I know what you’re thinking. What does some random guy with a stupid film degree think is going to happen? Well, good news! Because I’m about to make my predictions on who and what will take home the big prizes at this year’s show.

 

I’ve decided to offer up two sets of picks, one Head Choice (what I think will probably win) and one Heart Choice (what I would I choose if I were in charge). I’m not going to do all of the awards, because that would be really boring, but here are my thoughts on what we might see this Sunday, as Hollywood gets together to talk about how great they all are.


Best Original Song

 

Head Choice – What Was I Made For?

 

The emotional ballad from the Barbie movie, as performed by Billie Eilish, has been getting the most praise from the awards leading up to the Oscars, including a couple of Grammy wins.

 

Eilish is a former winner and the Academy would love the chance to give a young woman two wins in quick succession, so I think this one is in the bag.

 

Heart Choice – I’m Just Ken

 

I like What Was I Made For?, but come on. Ryan Gosling’s big musical number in Barbie is the highlight of the film and I’m Just Ken has had the most cultural impact out of any of the songs nominated. By the way, one of the nominees is from a musical about Cheetos? When did that happen?

 

Anyway, Gosling basically redefined his career with this song, and at least we’ll get to see him do it live at the ceremony.

 

Best Animated Feature

 

Head Choice – The Boy and the Heron

 

Hayao Miyazaki’s “final” film (watch that change) has been very warmly received by critics, with many citing it as a return to form for the old master. It’s got a great story behind it and Miyazaki has won before, so it feels pretty nailed on that the Academy will want to give him a big send-off.

 

I liked The Boy and the Heron, but I didn’t love it in the way many others did. Sue me.

 

Heart Choice – Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse

 

What I do love are the Spider-Verse movies and I thought Across was the best Spider-Man film I have ever seen, animated or otherwise. As well as being a great story, the film is also stunning and makes great use of its animated setting. I think it looks better than The Boy and the Heron and I think it’s an overall better piece.

 

Again, sue me.

  

Best Original Screenplay

 

Head Choice – The Holdovers

 

I don’t see The Holdovers winning much in the bigger categories over Oppenheimer, so I could see them giving it something in a category in which Oppy isn’t nominated.

 

David Hemingson’s script has won a couple of awards in the build-up, and it would be nice to see someone win on their first nomination.

 

Heart Choice – Past Lives

 

Past Lives has to win something. It’s an utter sensation and I think the screenplay, though not the major selling point of the film, was really good.

 

It’s not a massively dialogue-heavy film, but what is said is so vital to this gorgeous story. Celine Song isn’t nominated for Best Director (a crime), so give her this. Please.

 

Best Adapted Screenplay

 

Head Choice – Oppenheimer

 

It’s going to win all the awards, so it might as well win this.

 

I don’t really have much else to say – we’re going to be talking about Oppenheimer a lot.

 

Heart Choice – American Fiction

 

One of the snappiest, sharpest, funniest scripts I’ve seen in some time, American Fiction is all about the dialogue, so Cord Jefferson deserves huge praise for converting Percival Everett’s novel Erasure for the big screen.

 

It’s a film about writing, for goodness’ sake.

 

Best Supporting Actor

 

Head Choice – Robert Downey Jr.

 

I do not get this one at all. I thought RDJ was thoroughly average as Lewis Strauss in Oppenheimer, yet everyone is heralding it as the second coming of Gielgud.

 

He will win this award, because he’s won it pretty much everywhere else, and I will continue to be baffled.  


Heart Choice – Robert de Niro

 

I was very vocal in my dislike of Killers of the Flower Moon, which speaks volumes to how good I thought de Niro was as evil puppet master William “King” Hale. Conniving and wily with a great human touch, King was easily the best part of a thoroughly draining experience, so why not give the Dirty Grandpa something else for his trophy case.

 

Mark Ruffalo in Poor Things was in close second – Duncan Wedderburn is my problematic hero.

 

Best Supporting Actress

 

Head Choice – Da’Vine Joy Randolph

 

Again, I don’t get this one, but Randolph’s turn as bereaved chef Mary Lamb in The Holdovers is on a massive run of form right now, so it seems nailed on to win here.

 

I’m less angry about this than Downey because Randolph seems to be having a total blast on the award circuit. I dare anyone to watch her BAFTAs speech and not come away a fan.

 

Heart Choice – Nobody

 

I’ve genuinely got nothing. It doesn’t help that I haven’t seen Nyad or The Color Purple; America Ferrara gave one incredible speech in Barbie, but that’s it; and Emily Blunt looked really bored in Oppenheimer.


Can I pick Tracee Ellis Ross from American Fiction? She’s not nominated, but she was great.

 

Best Director

 

Head Choice – Christopher Nolan

 

Just get it over with already. Give the Nolan Bros their precious Oscar and let’s end all discussion about one of the most overhyped movies of the 21st Century.

 

Nolan 100% deserves recognition for his body of work, but I don’t know why Oppenheimer is the one to finally bring him the tiny gold man.

 

Heart Choice – Jonathan Glazer

 

So much of why The Zone of Interest works is down to Glazer’s incredible direction. The camera set-up in the house, the decision to film in night-vision, the naturalistic tone of the actors, it’s his doing and it’s all incredible.

 

Nobody else comes close to his work this year and it’s going to be so sad when Nolan obliterates him.

 

Best Actor

 

Head Choice – Cillian Murphy

 

Of all the things Oppenheimer is going to win, this one irks me the least. Cillian Murphy was genuinely good as the titular character, commanding a lot of screen time across a very long film.

 

Sure, his portrayal was nothing like the actual man, but for an adaptation, he did a wonderful job.

 

Heart Choice – Jeffrey Wright

 

There were many reasons why I liked American Fiction and the central performance of Jeffrey Wright as sardonic writer Thelonius “Monk” Ellison was a big one. He was equally likeable and hateable, funny and frustrating, righteous and pompous all at once, and here’s hoping this isn’t the last time Wright gets a nod.

 

I didn’t see Rustin, but I heard Colman Domingo was good.

 

Best Actress

 

Head Choice – Emma Stone

 

Emma Stone as Bella Baxter in Poor Things could have also been my Heart Choice, because I loved her portrayal of the eccentric, independent heroine. It was a full body performance, plenty of physical acting as well as speech, and Stone completely made the character her own. 


I wouldn’t be upset if she won, and she’s got a very strong chance alongside Lily Gladstone, but one leading lady captured my heart a teensy bit more.

 

Heart Choice – Carey Mulligan


Maestro wouldn’t have been nearly as good were it not for Carey Mulligan and her astounding turn as Felicia Montealgre, Leonard Bernstein’s loving yet stifled wife. In a story supposedly about Lenny, she was the star. Kind and gentle, even when angry, she was captivating in every way.


I was strongly moved by her big speech towards the end of the film, the best performance from any nominees across all the acting categories. She won’t win, by my God does she deserve some recognition. 

 

Best Picture

 

Head Choice - Oppenheimer


I mean, it’s just going to win, isn’t it. Christopher Nolan’s Oppenheimer has steamrolled everything in its path since the awards corridor opened and it seems unlikely that anything will derail its charge prior to the big night. 


A Nolan joint has never won Best Picture before, so it feels even more certain that they’ll do it this time. I’m not saying he doesn’t deserve an award for something, just not this. 

 

Heart Choice – The Zone of Interest

 

As much as I loved Past Lives, nothing in the field of Oscar contenders felt as important as Jonathan Glazer’s The Zone of Interest. A stunning vision of a modern historical monster that makes him somehow less and more terrifying all at once, it’s a monumental, special piece of cinema that did everything right. 


Oppy has it in the bag, but I’m more than happy to nail my flag to the mast of this exceptional loser. 


 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page