My 10 Least Favourite Taylor Swift Songs

It’s New Taylor Swift Album Day! Hooray!
As we all digest The Tortured Poets Department and wait to see if that awful name was worth it, I think it’s helpful to remind ourselves that, although she has gifted the world with many great songs, not everything Queen Midas has touched has turned to gold.
To be clear, I think Taylor has way more good songs than bad. On the big list I have, only 12 scored lower than a 3/5, and that’s out of 144 total tunes. However, when she gets it wrong, she gets it really wrong, as you’re about to find out.
Apologise in advance, but if any of these are your favourite, then I think we may have to stop being friends.
#10: Stay Stay Stay
From the plinky-plonky opening to “Stay Stay Stay” from Red, you know you’re in for a bad time.
This song, which begins with Taylor assaulting her fictional partner by throwing her phone at him, is meant to be this twee love song about how she wants him to, well, stay.
It sounds like children’s music with lyrics to boot, especially the cringe-inducing repetitive chorus, which could have been lifted straight from Sesame Street without anyone noticing.
The lyrics are equally juvenile, with lines like “But you carry my groceries and now I'm always laughing”. So, is she laughing because he’s carrying her groceries? What’s funny about that?
Unless there’s some secret joke that I’m not in on, then I really don’t understand why this got made. Red is meant to be Taylor’s big coming out party, her ascension to the status of great modern songwriter, and yet here we are with something that she should have been ashamed to have penned as a teenager.
Now, if you’ll excuse me, I need to go laugh at the people in the Sainsbury’s car park.
#9: Fifteen
To give TayTay some credit, she was only four years removed from actually being 15 when this song was written, but I was in my twenties when I first heard this song from Fearless, so excuse me for rolling my eyes.
An ode to starting high school, “Fifteen” is a checklist of all the cliches you’ve seen in teen movies. Making a new best friend? Check. Dreaming about leaving your dead-end town? Check. Meeting a cute boy with a car, which really freaked me out because apparently American kids can drive at 16? Check.
I would imagine the appeal in this song comes from it being “relatable”, but to me - who admittedly never went to an American high school, although there’s still time - this feels extremely basic. I probably could have come up with most of these examples from watching old episodes of Glee, and I’m sure there are much more imaginative tunes about similar experiences.
Something like this was never going to hold up well with hindsight and the fact that Taylor has matured so much in the public eye only makes it worse. Maybe this song is like the Vietnam War - I’ll never know, because I wasn’t there.
#8: How You Get The Girl
“How You Get the Girl” is 1989’s version of “Stay Stay Stay” - a massive outlier that reveals itself from the very first note.
It follows the same basic premise; a couple fight; there’s a romantic gesture from the guy; the girl is immediately swept up in the situation and forgives him. Only this time, I don’t think there was any battery.
The song is set to a dance pop backing that, if it didn’t have the lyrics, you’d mistake for something from the YouTube audio library. It sounds like Max Martin whipped it up in about five minutes, which is four minutes longer than it should have taken, and offers very little beyond a basic human desire to move along to a rhythm.
And then there’s this abomination - “Remind her how it used to be, be/Yeah, with pictures in frames of kisses on cheeks, cheeks”.
This is an all-time bad Swift lyric and the worst part is that it comes back later in the song! How did nobody read this without throwing up, let alone mentioning that it might need tweaking?
Similarly to “Stay Stay Stay”, I have no idea how this made it out of the studio.
#7: Never Grow Up
I’m a big defender of Speak Now. There are only two real clangers on there; "Last Kiss" (which was number 11) and this.
“Never Grow Up” is Taylor ostensibly talking to a child about the dangers of getting older, but she’s actually giving advice to a younger version of herself, which I only just learned. Similarly to “Fifteen”, she attempts to capitalise on a universal experience, but lacks the songwriting chops to do it in a meaningful way.
She talks about her mum dropping her off at the movies and dancing round the house in her pyjamas, but there’s no sentiment to any of these moments. It’s just a list of things that kids do in the hope that the listener will attach their own feelings to them - you can’t just throw an egg in someone’s face and hope it reminds them of a nice omelette they once had.
Overly sentimental and poorly executed, "Never Grow Up" isn’t offensive or anything, it’s just not a good song. Also, between this and “Fifteen”, I can’t work out if Taylor liked being a teenager or not.
#6: Change
The USA won more medals than anyone else at the 2008 Summer Olympics, which is doubly impressive when you realise this was one of the songs on their official playlist.
Released initially as part of the AT&T Team USA Soundtrack, “Change” also appeared on Fearless and it really is rotten. There’s nothing’s wrong with the song itself, which is a pretty standard guitar-driven tune about how life always gets better, but the actual recording is complete trash.
Am I mad, or is Taylor massively out of tune? On the original album, I mean - if I start getting into the weeds with “Taylor’s Version”, then I’ll go mad.
Her singing voice isn't that strong across this entire album, but “Change” is genuinely ear-shredding at points. She wails with the horror of an 18th century ghost and the song itself isn’t interesting enough for me not to notice.
This might just be a me thing, but I remember being appalled when I first heard this song. God bless the Olympians for putting up with this, although let’s be honest, most of them probably never even listened.
#5: Mary’s Song (Oh My My My)
This song comes from T-Swizzle’s self-titled debut release, which means it’s time to talk about one of my least favourite genres in all of music - 21st Century country.
“Mary’s Song (Oh My My My)”, which is a hideous title, is a story about two people (one of whom I assume is called Mary) who have known each other since childhood.
Their daddies used to joke about them getting hitched one day, whilst their mamas rolled their eyes, and one day they noticed that neither one was a little kid anymore, and I wish I was making any of this up.
If you’re one of those people who binges crappy Hallmark Christmas movies every year, then this is the song for you. It’s every hackneyed, maligned, laughable stereotype rolled into one vomit-inducing package with a horrible refrain that was clearly only added to hook in listeners on country radio stations.
There is nothing genuine about this sort of music, especially when it’s coming from a girl who grew up in West Reading, Pennsylvania. And it isn’t even the worse one on the debut.
#4: You Need To Calm Down
“Shade never made anybody less gay”
Honestly, the whole review could just be that line.
I don’t even know where to start with the story of “You Need to Calm Down”. I like Lover quite a bit, despite some of the songs coming up in this countdown, but this feels like a hangover from Reputation, a boastful, self-obsessed track that paints Taylor in a really ugly light.
That’s the first verse anyway, where she takes shots at her “haters” and people who call her out on the Internet. The second verse inexplicably compares her experiences with those of the Queer community, which was definitely a choice.
I really don’t think Taylor Swift is a bad person, but this was so badly thought out. You can tell that not a single queer person was shown this song before it got released, otherwise it would never have been allowed out. And it was one of the main singles from the album! It got a music video and everything!
A mistake like this would have killed a lesser artist stone dead, so in a way it’s a testament to the power Swift has in our culture. But my God, what was she thinking?
#3: Our Song
This song makes me want to throw up.
We’re back in country-town with our second trip to the album Taylor Swift and its regrettable closer, “Our Song”. It’s about a simple country gal and her simple country guy. They don’t have a proper “song” together, but rather their “song” is the sound of all the things they do together!
Fetch the bucket.
First of all, I hate songs about songs. I don’t know why, they just feel icky. Secondly, all those Kentucky-fried tropes I got mad at before are back, but way worse. The Taylor Twang, which mysteriously disappeared after she got more famous, is in full effect, as she sings about screen doors and porches and riding in her man’s pickup truck and other things she plucked out of the Big Book of Country Cliches.
This is production line country at its absolute nadir without a hint of genuine humanity in sight. The jug band-level music, the bingo card lyrics, that bloody twang, it all needs to go in the bin - this is easily the worst song off Taylor’s first album.
I suppose everyone has to start somewhere, even if it is right at the very bottom.
#2: London Boy
“London Boy” from Lover is the ultimate “why did this get made?” song from Swift’s catalogue. We get it, mate, you’re dating a Brit. That is not an excuse to cram as many references to the UK as possible into three minutes.
It’s like that Simpsons episode where the family come to the UK, only with a cameo from Idris Elba instead of Tony Blair. If it had been Tony, it would have gotten a much better score.
Did Taylor think this would score her points on her citizenship test or something? Namechecking parts of London like Brixton and Shoreditch (which must have really confused American fans) and referencing rugby, which she painfully rhymes with “in the pub we”?
And then there’s the music, this bizarre, almost dream-like purgatory between a serious pop song and incidental music from a bad sitcom. There’s no obvious hook or catchy melody, it’s like it’s intentionally stripped back to give more room to the lyrics, which is very much not a good thing.
“London Boy” feels like a wink and a nudge between Taylor and Joe Alwyn, and there is nothing more annoying than two people who don’t include you in their in-jokes.
Hopefully Idris got a nice payday out of this.
#1: Me!
Ughhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh.
It says a lot that I like Lover as much as I do, considering it contains three of Taylor’s four worst songs and this, the very bottom of the pile.
“Me!” is almost so bad it isn’t even a song. It’s an exuberant carnival tune full of bits and pieces that sound like they belong to different songs, but just bang into and off of each other like oppositely polarised magnets.
There’s the “cool chicks/lame guys” part, which was outdated ten years before this song was released, the “one of these things is not like the other” pre-chorus, which she clearly stole from Instagram, and Brendon Urie, maybe her weirdest collaborator ever. And I’m including the Snow Patrol guy.
Then there’s the absolute worst part of the song and maybe of Taylor’s entire discography - the infamous “Spelling is fun!” segment.
There is not a “Me” in “Team”. There is an “M” and an “E”, but not in that order. You know what there is a “Me” in? “Crime Against Humanity”, which this song is.
Overbearing, badly constructed, and just plain annoying, “Me!” isn’t just TayTay’s worst song, but it might be the worst pop song from a major artist I have ever heard.



Comments