Dune (1984) - What... Just What? (Dune Season)
If you’ve read my recent review of Denis Villeneuve’s second entry into the modern Dune series of films, then you’ll know that I am a huge fan of what he’s been able to do with this purportedly unfilmable subject.
As a great admirer of the Dune story, I thought I owed it to myself to check out the infamous 1984 version directed by David Lynch; a film so terrible it killed any serious attempts to bring Frank Herbert’s novel to the big screen for the next four decades. Surely it can’t be that bad, I thought to myself.
Oh, but it could. It could be that bad.
My first hurdle was how to actually view this movie. Not in terms of where it was available to stream (it’s on Amazon Prime), but rather how to review it in the light of Villeneuve’s triumphs. It would be unfair to judge something made in the 80s by today’s standards, but it’s almost impossible not to considering they are so historically intertwined. I tried to be as objective as possible, having also not read the original novel, but I am only human, so forgive me if my biases get in the way.
That being said, I don’t know how helpful it was to have seen the 2020s films after all. I thought I knew this story, but once I’d reached the end of Dune ‘84, I wasn’t so sure.
It was always going to be a struggle to cram the entire first book into one two-hour movie (Denis took about six hours to get it done) but there were things it could have done differently to give itself a better chance. A lot of the Dune mythology contains unusual words and ideas, which were not given enough time. It wasn’t properly explained what Shai-Hulud meant or how the concept was significant to the Fremen people and very little thought was given to explaining the concept of Kwisatz Haderach. I knew what was going on because I’d seen the other films, but if I’d come to the story this way first, I’d have had no clue.
The characters were woefully underdeveloped, another casualty of time constraints. The Emperor’s Bene Gesserit, played superbly by Charlotte Rampling in the modern films, was in about three scenes, even though she is utterly crucial to the story. None of the Fremen were given any personality and were clearly there purely to serve as fodder for the fight scenes, which leads me to the most tragic victim of this whole project - Chani.
In the Villenueve films, Zendaya (once she showed up) brought nuance and vulnerability to the character and was just below Paul in terms of importance and prominence. Here, Sean Young is barely even there; she turns up, is placed into a relationship with Paul immediately, and that’s it. It’s incredible that these two portrayals are of the same character.
The only person who got more development in the Lynch version was the Emperor, but that’s only because Christopher Walken wasn’t there looking like he’d gotten lost on the way to bingo.
There’s not much point talking about the actors, because the dialogue they were given was so bad that it completely negated any of their abilities. When they weren’t spelling out the plot in excruciating detail, characters were giving verbose speeches that even Shakespeare would have thought were a bit much. Baron Harkonennon, who is such a menacing presence in the modern films, was reduced to pantomime status, at one point being referred to as a “flying fat man”. Also, about 50% of all speech in Dune was delivered via inner monologue, which gets super tiring after a while.
I won’t laugh at the special effects (even though I could), because they could only work with what was available at the time. What I will say is that the shields are absolutely hilarious; Paul and Geddy’s early fight is literally two rectangles bashing into each other and I question anyone who can watch this and not bust a gut. One thing that did look pretty good were the worms, even if they were quite clearly puppets, but short of actually breeding a race of gigantic desert monsters, this was the best they could have done.
My prevailing emotion towards David Lynch’s Dune is not annoyance that it was so bad or anger that I paid actual human money to watch it, but rather one of pity. There was so much working against this team that it would have taken intervention from the Mahdi himself for them to produce something half decent. The technology simply did not exist to do the scope of this story any sort of justice, and Dune’s flush had already been busy by over a decade’s worth of development hell.
However, it’s not all doom and gloom. Several design elements (particularly the Fremen costumes) clearly served as an inspiration for the Villenueve pictures and elements of Toto’s score (yes, the music was done by the Africa band) reappear in Hans Zimmer’s fantastic modern soundtrack.
Above everything else, Dune ‘84 showed the modern films precisely what not to do, and for that, I am eternally grateful.




Comments