top of page
Search

All Of Us Strangers - Love And Grief Make A Flawless Pair... Almost (Cinema Review)

jacobtsimmons97
Feb 13, 2024
4 min read

The cast list for Andrew Haigh’s All of Us Strangers is just six people. Do you know how excited that makes me? Small, personal films are my jam, and this one ticked so many of my pretentious little boxes. Unfortunately, for all the good it did, there was one major obstacle it failed to cross on its way to true greatness.


One of the six people involved in this project is Adam, played by sexy priest/sexy Moriarty/ sexy Irishman Andrew Scott. He’s a writer, so, naturally, he’s desperately lonely, until he meets person 2/6, Paul Mescal’s Harry. If you want to hear Mescal doing a Northern English accent whilst sporting the most borderline-beard moustache of all time, then this is the movie for you. 


Harry presents himself as a romantic option for Adam, but, as the old saying goes, there’s no greater cockblock than returning to your old family home and discovering the ghosts of your parents, who died when you were a child. I think Oscar Wilde wrote that. 


This is the main hook of the film; Adam’s interactions with persons 3 and 4, dad Jamie Bell and mum Claire Foy. Haigh adapted this idea from a Japanese novel called Strangers by Taichi Yamada, which was originally adapted for the screen in 1988. This version is pretty different from what I can tell, with an entirely new queer angle, but the core question remains the same - what would you do if you had a second chance with your parents? 


Those who have heard of Bell and Foy will know that they aren’t old enough to be Scott’s parents. That’s because the ghosts are the age at which they died, meaning Adam and his ‘rents are now effectively the same age. Just in case this already harrowing situation wasn’t bad enough. This leads to some really interesting dynamics between the two parties; Adam can’t help but regress to childhood, even sleeping in his parents’ bed in one scene, whilst on the other hand, mum and dad have been dead since the 80s, and rely on their son to fill them in on current affairs. By this, I mean Adam’s mum has a very hard time understanding how gay people work. 


Adam’s parents aren't homophobes or anything, they’re just products of their time. Sadly, this has had a profound effect on their son, who struggles mightily to accept love. The parallels between Adam coming to terms with his folks and his new relationship are masterfully done; subtle and slight, allowing the viewer to draw their own conclusions rather than shoving it down anyone’s throats. This ties into the film’s big message; to enjoy the present, you must come to terms with the past. And when your present is Paul Mescal, you’ll definitely want to enjoy it. 


I could go on about how amazing the story of this film is, but I feel like I should probably talk about the actual filmmaking on this film blog. I know, right, what a buzzkill.


The cinematography is stunning, with lots of beautifully tinted shots of the London skyline in the Adam and Harry scenes and a homely 80s glow bathing his parents’ house. Haigh shoots the film to be as evocative as possible, particularly with his use of mirrors. Characters turn up in reflections all the time, looking at themselves, somebody else, or nothing at all. If I had to assign some sort of symbolism to this, I’d probably say that it was to do with Adam’s inability to see himself or how much “reflecting” he does in this story, but honestly, that feels seriously GCSE English. Sometimes, a motif doesn’t have to be glaring obvious; if it makes you feel something, then that’s enough. It drives me crackers when filmmakers overload movies with metaphors, so it was nice that this one was left as ambiguous as it was. 


I’ve gushed about this film enough, so now it’s time for me to take it down a peg or two. Ok, that’s a slight exaggeration, but I am going to get negative now. Also, major spoilers ahead. 


After a gloriously tearful goodbye between Adam and his parents (which takes place in a bloody shopping centre food court, of all places), our protagonist goes to find Harry, ready to put the past behind him and start looking forward. As Adam searches his beau’s room, it becomes apparent that something is horribly wrong. He pushes open the door to his bedroom and there it is; Harry is dead. 


Look, I get why this might work for some people. Adam’s obsession with the past cost him a chance at love, so he needs to take this onboard for his next relationship. The fact he then sees Harry as a ghost means he has to let him go too, which is how the movie ends. But come on - can’t we give the guy a break? 


The tonal whiplash from the food court scene to Harry’s death is too much. Maybe it works better in the book, where it might have more time to breathe, but at a relatively trim 106 minutes, All of Us Strangers doesn’t have the room for this to be fully effective. The heartbreak is too sudden, leaving me numb to the situation instead of fully invested. Also, there’s something mildly sinister about the gay man who can’t be happy in his relationship; I feel like it would have been a more powerful statement to let Harry live. 


It doesn’t help that the final scene plays out to Frankie Goes to Hollwyood’s The Power of Love, a song I cannot stand. 


Ultimately, all this accomplished was knocking All of Us Strangers down from “basically perfect” to “very, very good”, but I really wanted it to be “basically perfect”. This film came so tantalisingly close to cracking a very special place in my heart, but the ending scuppered those chances, and no one is more upset about that than me. Still, I would be a fool not to acknowledge everything it did right; it is a beautiful picture in so many different ways, and if you were able to enjoy it to the full extent, then all the power to you. 


Oh, and in case you’re wondering, the other two people in the film are “Young Adam” and a waitress at the food court whose face we never see. Love it. 


 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page